The Difference Between the 4 Madhabs in Islamic Inheritance
All four Sunni schools of thought — Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, and Hanbali — agree on the overwhelming majority of Islamic inheritance law. The fixed shares prescribed in Surah An-Nisa 4:11, 4:12, and 4:176 are accepted without divergence. The basic blocking rules are shared. The priority of debts over inheritance is universal. Where the madhabs differ is in a set of specific edge cases — situations the Quran addressed less explicitly and where the companions and their successors held differing views. These differences are genuine and practically significant: the same family, with the same estate, can reach different distributions depending on which madhab is applied.
What All Four Madhabs Agree On
Before examining the differences, it is important to understand the breadth of the consensus. The following are universally agreed across all four madhabs:
- The six Quranic fractions (1/2, 1/4, 1/8, 1/3, 2/3, 1/6)
- The 2:1 ratio between sons and daughters as residuary heirs
- The spousal shares (wife 1/4, or 1/8 with a child or son's child; husband 1/2, or 1/4 with a child or son's child)
- That debts and funeral costs take priority over all inheritance shares
- That the wasiyyah is capped at one-third and cannot be made to a Faraid heir (Sunan Abi Dawud 2870); the jurists let the other heirs' consent after the death validate such a bequest, each heir's consent binding only their own share (Ibn Qudama, al-Mughni)
- That a Muslim and a non-Muslim do not inherit from each other: "A Muslim cannot be the heir of a disbeliever, nor can a disbeliever be the heir of a Muslim" (Sahih al-Bukhari 6764 (opens in a new tab))
- The Awl (proportional reduction) mechanism when fixed shares exceed the estate
Difference 1: The Grandfather and Sibling Conflict
The most practically significant difference between the madhabs concerns what happens when a paternal grandfather and full siblings both survive the deceased. This is the classical grandfather-sibling problem debated by the companions of the Prophet ﷺ.
| Madhab | Grandfather vs siblings: outcome |
|---|---|
| Hanafi | Grandfather completely blocks all siblings. Siblings receive nothing when grandfather is alive. |
| Maliki | Grandfather shares as one more brother: Muqasama (best of sharing, 1/3 of the residue or 1/6 of the estate). |
| Shafi'i | Muqasama (best of sharing, 1/3 of the residue or 1/6 of the estate). Same approach as Maliki. |
| Hanbali | Muqasama (best of sharing, 1/3 of the residue or 1/6 of the estate). Same approach as Maliki and Shafi'i. |
In the Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali schools, which follow the method of Zayd ibn Thabit (RA), the grandfather shares with the siblings as one more brother. When a fixed-share heir is also present, he takes the best of three: his share by sharing, one third of what remains after the fixed shares, or one sixth of the whole estate. When none is present, he takes the better of sharing or one third of the whole estate (Muwatta Malik, Book 27, Hadith 31 (opens in a new tab)). The Hanafi school follows the view of Abu Bakr (RA) that the grandfather excludes the siblings.
The practical impact is significant. In a Hanafi estate where a grandfather and three full brothers survive, the brothers receive nothing. In a Maliki, Shafi'i, or Hanbali estate with the same family, the brothers share alongside the grandfather.
This grandfather-sibling disagreement is also what drives the Akdariyya, one of the best-known special cases in Faraid. The donkey case (Mushtaraka) is a separate dispute, not a grandfather case: with a husband, a mother or grandmother, two or more uterine siblings and full brothers, the Maliki and Shafi'i schools let the full brothers share the uterine third equally, while the Hanafi and Hanbali schools give them nothing.
Difference 2: Whether Radd Is Applied at All
Radd is the mechanism that returns surplus estate to fixed-share heirs when no residuary (Asabah) heir exists. The schools differ on whether it is applied at all, not on whether the spouse takes part in it.
| Madhab | Radd applied? |
|---|---|
| Hanafi | Yes. The surplus returns to the non-spouse fixed-share heirs. |
| Maliki | Classically no: the surplus goes to the Bayt al-Mal. Some later scholars return it to the non-spouse fixed-share heirs where the Bayt al-Mal is not properly administered. |
| Shafi'i | Classically no: the surplus goes to the Bayt al-Mal. Later Shafi'i scholars (Ibn Hajar al-Haytami 6/390 to 6/392) return it to the non-spouse fixed-share heirs where the Bayt al-Mal is not properly administered. |
| Hanbali | Yes. The surplus returns to the non-spouse fixed-share heirs. |
In every school that applies Radd, the husband or wife does not share in it while other fixed-share heirs survive. Where Radd is applied, take a widow, daughters and the deceased's mother, with no Asabah heir: the widow receives only her fixed 1/8 and the surplus returns to the daughters and the mother. Where a spouse is the only heir, the position is disputed, so ask a qualified scholar.
Difference 3: Dhawul Arham (Distant Relatives)
When no fixed-share heir and no Asabah heir survives, who inherits? The madhabs differ significantly.
| Madhab | Dhawul Arham inherit? |
|---|---|
| Hanafi | Yes. Dhawul Arham inherit when no closer heir exists. |
| Maliki | Classically no: the estate goes to the public treasury (Bayt al-Mal). |
| Shafi'i | Classically no: the estate goes to the Bayt al-Mal. |
| Hanbali | Yes. Dhawul Arham inherit, as in the Hanafi school. |
A Point of Agreement: The Gharrawain Rule
When a spouse and both parents survive, with no child or son's child and fewer than two siblings, a straightforward calculation gives the mother 1/3 of the full estate, which can exceed the father's residue. The Gharrawain rule gives the mother 1/3 of the remainder after the spouse's share instead, so the father takes double the mother.
All four madhabs apply it, so it is not a difference between them. Imam Malik sets out both cases in the Muwatta: with a husband or a wife and both parents, the mother takes "a third of what remains" (Muwatta Malik, Book 27, Fara'id (opens in a new tab)). That is 1/6 of the estate beside a husband and 1/4 beside a wife. For the other three schools, see our Hanafi, Shafi'i and Hanbali guides.
Full Comparison at a Glance
| Issue | Hanafi | Maliki | Shafi'i | Hanbali |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grandfather vs siblings | Grandfather blocks siblings | Muqasama (best of sharing, 1/3 of the residue or 1/6 of the estate) | Muqasama (best of sharing, 1/3 of the residue or 1/6 of the estate) | Muqasama (best of sharing, 1/3 of the residue or 1/6 of the estate) |
| Radd applied at all | Yes | Classically no | Classically no | Yes |
| Dhawul Arham inherit | Yes | Classically no | Classically no | Yes |
| Mushtaraka (donkey case) | Full brothers get nothing | Share the uterine third | Share the uterine third | Full brothers get nothing |
| Father beside paternal grandmother | Father excludes her | Father excludes her | Father excludes her | She inherits beside him |
| Gharrawain rule (agreed) | Yes (Hanafi guide) | Yes (Muwatta Malik, Book 27 (opens in a new tab)) | Yes (Shafi'i guide) | Yes (Hanbali guide) |
Which Madhab Should You Use?
Apply the madhab the deceased followed during their lifetime. If that is unclear, ask a local scholar who knows the deceased's community and practice.
The FaraidHub calculator supports all four madhabs. Select the correct madhab before entering heirs. The engine applies the right rules automatically, including the grandfather-sibling interaction and Radd. For the Maliki and Shafi'i schools the calculator follows the later scholars and returns the surplus by Radd; the spouse takes no part while other fixed-share heirs survive. It does not model Dhawul Arham heirs, so ask a local scholar where they would inherit.
Explore Each Madhab in Detail
Calculate Using the Deceased's Madhab
Select the madhab the deceased followed, and the engine applies the correct rules automatically.
Open the Faraid Calculator →